Discussion about this post

User's avatar
John Oakley's avatar

Lee Kuan Yew’s great book about Singapore's transformation “from third world to first” should be required reading for all politicians.

I first visited Singapore over 30 years ago and was warned by my colleagues that it was an unbelievable dictatorship. When I deplaned, I thought they were right because the first sign I saw was "The penalty for the possession of drugs is DEATH". The second was "Welcome to Singapore".

I had planned to meet my contact the next day, and I walked to his office, thinking it would help my jet lag. I was impressed by the happy, smiling faces I passed. When I reached my destination, I went in to be greeted by a charming receptionist. When I identified myself, she checked her messages and apologized that my contact had been unavoidably detained, and she had rescheduled the meeting for the afternoon. "Take a look around our beautiful city," she suggested. And it was. No graffiti. No sign of litter. A few private cars and many taxis. And everyone seemed to be happy.

I returned to the office in the afternoon to be met by an apologetic receptionist who told me that the man I was supposed to see would not be available for a week. When I asked for the reason, she told me that he would be in a re-education class for the rest of the week. I insisted on seeing his superior, and he appeared quickly.

He took me to the spotless cafe next door and explained the man I'd come to see had been sentenced that morning to a re-education class because he'd repeatedly dropped his cigarette end/butt in the street.

We talked over coffee about living in this repressive regime. I asked if all the smiles were genuine, and he was adamant they were. People lived in a virtually crime-free society because there were strict rules under Lee Kuan Yew. And they knew that if they committed a crime, the punishments were harsh. They also knew all their news was censored, but they were happy about that too. And cricket was their national sport!

I had come to Singapore to negotiate a 12-month assignment for one of my team members at one of their facilities (and to see if his wife and daughter would be able to bear it).

They stayed for 3 years.

I visited them several times, and they were adamant that they would no longer be happy with "freedom".

John Moss's avatar

New York had 'anti-idling' laws. They issued about 100,000 fines a year.

Then, they changed the rules on evidence for this and accepted videos sent in by the public. If that led to the $300 fine being paid, the person who sent in the video got $100.

The number of fines went up to over 1 million in the first year.

Citizen reporting of grafitti, parking offences, fly-tipping etc ought to be encouraged in the same way here.

11 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?