This section on ILR reform is fascinating, because it's a Tory MP complaining that Labour aren't doing enough to undo damage caused by the Tory party. Well, I certainly agree with that!
Thanks Neil. I always read your pieces with interest and admire the hard work you put into getting to grips with the detail. It would be great if you and others in your party start making a more positive case for a controlled immigration policy i.e. to attract highly skilled immigrants that will make a net positive contribution, to attract immigrants to fill vacancies that we cannot fill from current citizens, and to give shelter to genuine asylum seekers. But also tighten up on entry for family members, especially parents who will have a significant negative economic impact, and make faster decisions on asylum and removal. To the extent the ECHR is a problem with decisions and removal, can we take measures without having to leave ECHR, either by agreement with other signatories or in contravention of treaty without actually leaving it?
This is what the Conservatives should be looking at to try and win back your former seats that have gone LibDem, rather than chasing after Reform voters with an all immigration is bad message.
I did a piece on the fiscal cost of care worker visas. The MAC estimate of the discounted lifetime fiscal cost of each careworker visa (taxes paid minus government provided welfare, benefits and services consumed over their lifetime) is £36k, and £67k for each dependent.
But these are “discounted” costs over a lifetime. The costs include a bit of welfare benefits in the near term (after gaining ILR - five years after arriving migrants can claim universal credit etc). But the serious costs come in decades in the future when workers retire and they start to draw pensions and use expensive healthcare and social care, and these costs are heavily discounted in the MAC’s estimate. Each pound of positive tax contribution is counted as 97p in their first year here, but each pound of pension/health/social care cost is counted as 23p in retirement (after 50 years).
The MAC does not publish the undiscounted figures so I have a go at estimating them and got the lifetime fiscal cost of £430k per care worker and £490k per dependent. This means that the government’s estimate of total discounted lifetime fiscal cost of £10bn for careworker visas issued 2022-2024 equates to about £90bn if presented as undiscounted. This starts to get to triple lock levels of future costs (if low skilled migration continues).
Aside from any cultural aspects of migration, which is often the focus of the policy debate, we need to get better at assessing the economic aspects of migration. Not just the economic impact now (gdp, or lower cost of social care), but the fiscal impact in the future. The current model of low skilled migration makes future me poorer by quite a lot.
We have three choices to staff social care (or other low skill roles where we have shortages). We can either:
• Option 1 - Pay uk workers more now to work in social care. But this is obviously expensive (£1 per hour increase for social care workers would cost about ~ £4bn ish across the sector - but you’d also have to increase pay in adjacent sectors like NHS so it would cost more). And as well as moving some NEETs into social care work, and convincing a few people with PIPs to join the workforce (which is good- but expensive), you will probably also divert workers from more productive parts of the economy (tech or whatever) to less productive parts of the economy (like social care) which is the opposite of what we want to do of we want to raise our growth rate.
• Option 2 . Recruit internationally for low skilled social care roles, but do not offer ILR. Workers could come to fill shortages and leave after 5-10 years. This model is implicit in Burnham’s favoured EU model of immigration. The reason he says he likes EU migration is because workers come for a few years and then leave, so it does not create a big long term burden on tomorrow’s tax payers (“the wrong sort of immigration”). So I agree with Burnham that temporary migration is economically, and probably culturally, better for the UK, and this should be formalised. As Burnham pointed out coming to work in the UK for short periods was always a fairly standard working practice: workers come on temporary visas to pick fruit, help in seasonal roles, work as a plumber, or whatever, then leave. Burnham suggests we can do more of this “right sort of immigration” via Brejoin or free-movement which is fine. But we do not need to do this with the EU, we can offer temporary visas to anyone. We can can choose our own immigration policy that suits us. And my worry is that Burnham’s “Brexit led to the wrong sort of immigration” argument for Bre-entry might work for him as a cultural argument that might just about work in Makerfield, but German / French /Polish students or plumbers are not going to come in sufficient numbers to staff our social care. The EU that Burnham is harking back to (like much else) does not exist: in 2000 Polish GDP/cap was 40% of the UK’s. It is now 84% of the UK’s. They have caught up. There is not a queue of east European workers wanting to join our workforce never mind our social care sector, even if we offer generous retirement pensions healthcare and social care. The MAC reported that 0.1% of all health and social care visas (wider than social care) were issued to EEA applicants. Brejoin/free movement will not help staff social care/ healthcare whatever Burnham might say.
- Option 3 Do as we do now: internationally recruit lots of low skilled cheap workers into the economy with the promise of ILR, and make ourselves richer today as social care is cheaper, deliveroo is cheaper, uber is cheaper, Amazon delivery is cheaper. But not worry that our kids are poorer, because, well, that’s tomorrow’s problem. And when policy people do the math, tomorrow (ie our kids future) is discounted more than today, so it all adds up.
So I would say:
- I’m all for immigration: high skilled immigration will make everyone more prosperous. The UK has a huge opportunity to attract the best and brightest from around the world. We will all be better off with more very high skilled immigration (we’ll be more prosperous now, but also in the future when we pay for migrants pensions and healthcare). This should unashamedly be a core part of our growth plan. But low skilled immigration (with ILR) makes us prosperous today (stuff is cheaper), but the next generation poorer.
- The UK is a great place to work temporarily (as Burnham implicitly points out in his preferred Bre-join / free movement model of immigration). This should be the preferred model for low skilled migration.
- Above all, we will continue to need lots of people to work in our social care and healthcare sectors in decades to come. Burnham believes that a combination of persuading some NEETs / PIP recipients back into the workforce, plus opening the doors to German French Polish students will meet our needs. I’m personally not sure. Our health and social care needs will grow exponentially for about 50 years (then decline rapidly). We need a way to sustainably staff our services in a way that we can afford, not just now, but into the future. Offering everyone a low wage job plus extremely generous retirement benefits paid for by tomorrow’s tax payers is not sustainable. Bre-entry / free movement is not an answer. Burnham has not said anything on this looming fiscal, social and health challenge.
Apologies - the response was too long, but hopefully I answered your question.
This section on ILR reform is fascinating, because it's a Tory MP complaining that Labour aren't doing enough to undo damage caused by the Tory party. Well, I certainly agree with that!
Thanks Neil. I always read your pieces with interest and admire the hard work you put into getting to grips with the detail. It would be great if you and others in your party start making a more positive case for a controlled immigration policy i.e. to attract highly skilled immigrants that will make a net positive contribution, to attract immigrants to fill vacancies that we cannot fill from current citizens, and to give shelter to genuine asylum seekers. But also tighten up on entry for family members, especially parents who will have a significant negative economic impact, and make faster decisions on asylum and removal. To the extent the ECHR is a problem with decisions and removal, can we take measures without having to leave ECHR, either by agreement with other signatories or in contravention of treaty without actually leaving it?
This is what the Conservatives should be looking at to try and win back your former seats that have gone LibDem, rather than chasing after Reform voters with an all immigration is bad message.
Thanks.
I did a piece on the fiscal cost of care worker visas. The MAC estimate of the discounted lifetime fiscal cost of each careworker visa (taxes paid minus government provided welfare, benefits and services consumed over their lifetime) is £36k, and £67k for each dependent.
But these are “discounted” costs over a lifetime. The costs include a bit of welfare benefits in the near term (after gaining ILR - five years after arriving migrants can claim universal credit etc). But the serious costs come in decades in the future when workers retire and they start to draw pensions and use expensive healthcare and social care, and these costs are heavily discounted in the MAC’s estimate. Each pound of positive tax contribution is counted as 97p in their first year here, but each pound of pension/health/social care cost is counted as 23p in retirement (after 50 years).
The MAC does not publish the undiscounted figures so I have a go at estimating them and got the lifetime fiscal cost of £430k per care worker and £490k per dependent. This means that the government’s estimate of total discounted lifetime fiscal cost of £10bn for careworker visas issued 2022-2024 equates to about £90bn if presented as undiscounted. This starts to get to triple lock levels of future costs (if low skilled migration continues).
Aside from any cultural aspects of migration, which is often the focus of the policy debate, we need to get better at assessing the economic aspects of migration. Not just the economic impact now (gdp, or lower cost of social care), but the fiscal impact in the future. The current model of low skilled migration makes future me poorer by quite a lot.
https://policystuffandting.substack.com/p/the-manana-manana-fiscal-cost-of?r=1qvfxt&utm_medium=ios
Wouldn't the pension cost be the same if we found someone to fulfil that care worker position, who was born and raised in the UK?
It’s a really good point.
We have three choices to staff social care (or other low skill roles where we have shortages). We can either:
• Option 1 - Pay uk workers more now to work in social care. But this is obviously expensive (£1 per hour increase for social care workers would cost about ~ £4bn ish across the sector - but you’d also have to increase pay in adjacent sectors like NHS so it would cost more). And as well as moving some NEETs into social care work, and convincing a few people with PIPs to join the workforce (which is good- but expensive), you will probably also divert workers from more productive parts of the economy (tech or whatever) to less productive parts of the economy (like social care) which is the opposite of what we want to do of we want to raise our growth rate.
• Option 2 . Recruit internationally for low skilled social care roles, but do not offer ILR. Workers could come to fill shortages and leave after 5-10 years. This model is implicit in Burnham’s favoured EU model of immigration. The reason he says he likes EU migration is because workers come for a few years and then leave, so it does not create a big long term burden on tomorrow’s tax payers (“the wrong sort of immigration”). So I agree with Burnham that temporary migration is economically, and probably culturally, better for the UK, and this should be formalised. As Burnham pointed out coming to work in the UK for short periods was always a fairly standard working practice: workers come on temporary visas to pick fruit, help in seasonal roles, work as a plumber, or whatever, then leave. Burnham suggests we can do more of this “right sort of immigration” via Brejoin or free-movement which is fine. But we do not need to do this with the EU, we can offer temporary visas to anyone. We can can choose our own immigration policy that suits us. And my worry is that Burnham’s “Brexit led to the wrong sort of immigration” argument for Bre-entry might work for him as a cultural argument that might just about work in Makerfield, but German / French /Polish students or plumbers are not going to come in sufficient numbers to staff our social care. The EU that Burnham is harking back to (like much else) does not exist: in 2000 Polish GDP/cap was 40% of the UK’s. It is now 84% of the UK’s. They have caught up. There is not a queue of east European workers wanting to join our workforce never mind our social care sector, even if we offer generous retirement pensions healthcare and social care. The MAC reported that 0.1% of all health and social care visas (wider than social care) were issued to EEA applicants. Brejoin/free movement will not help staff social care/ healthcare whatever Burnham might say.
- Option 3 Do as we do now: internationally recruit lots of low skilled cheap workers into the economy with the promise of ILR, and make ourselves richer today as social care is cheaper, deliveroo is cheaper, uber is cheaper, Amazon delivery is cheaper. But not worry that our kids are poorer, because, well, that’s tomorrow’s problem. And when policy people do the math, tomorrow (ie our kids future) is discounted more than today, so it all adds up.
So I would say:
- I’m all for immigration: high skilled immigration will make everyone more prosperous. The UK has a huge opportunity to attract the best and brightest from around the world. We will all be better off with more very high skilled immigration (we’ll be more prosperous now, but also in the future when we pay for migrants pensions and healthcare). This should unashamedly be a core part of our growth plan. But low skilled immigration (with ILR) makes us prosperous today (stuff is cheaper), but the next generation poorer.
- The UK is a great place to work temporarily (as Burnham implicitly points out in his preferred Bre-join / free movement model of immigration). This should be the preferred model for low skilled migration.
- Above all, we will continue to need lots of people to work in our social care and healthcare sectors in decades to come. Burnham believes that a combination of persuading some NEETs / PIP recipients back into the workforce, plus opening the doors to German French Polish students will meet our needs. I’m personally not sure. Our health and social care needs will grow exponentially for about 50 years (then decline rapidly). We need a way to sustainably staff our services in a way that we can afford, not just now, but into the future. Offering everyone a low wage job plus extremely generous retirement benefits paid for by tomorrow’s tax payers is not sustainable. Bre-entry / free movement is not an answer. Burnham has not said anything on this looming fiscal, social and health challenge.
Apologies - the response was too long, but hopefully I answered your question.
It’s not incredible at all when you reflect on the fact that these are all likely future Labour voters. Is it anything more complicated than that?