A billion is about 15 quid per person per year. Theres definitely improvements to be made, but this is sheer scapegoating of our minority communities (who also pay a lot of taxes). And coming from a Tory - The party who were literally responsible for years of austerity - it’s hypocrisy of the highest order - dont fall for this nonsense. Support your arts, they bring people together in so many ways.
If the author had chosen a different set of grants he could be be arguing for ACE instead of against - they support a wide range of projects.
Amazing list. Somehow the United States manages to have world class symphony orchestras, theaters, art museums, artists, actors, musicians, ballet and modern dance companies… some of whom apply for and receive small, specific grants from the National Endowment for the Arts, state and municipal grants, and a whole lot of private foundation and non-profit funding. Barbaric!
We live in an era when two inconsistent ideas rule the minds of many:
1) No one can determine that one artwork is better than another.
2) Everyone knows for certain that the job of government is to promote victims over oppressors, and everyone already knows who is worthy of such privilege.
I worked 25 years in mid scale theatre and most of the Arts Council Wales supported stuff was dross that nobody wanted to see, especially the Welsh language stuff!
As a theatre we eventually told ACW to get stuffed as they were too woke and controlling. It's proved a good commercial move.
This was covered in Bastiat’s ‘What is seen and what is not seen’ yet we still have the gov sticking its fingers in our pie and redistributing to favoured groups. We need to take a hatchet to the state so that ordinary people can benefit from their hard work.
My wife has spent 25 years slogging away earning a living as a performing musician. In all that time, as I've accompanied her on her travels, I've literally not seen a single ACE funded act which had any musical (or other) merit whatsoever.
The entertainment industry is very simple : if you are good enough, you can make a commercial living. If you're crap, then you can't, because nobody will pay money to see you. The entire ACE racket is an utter disgrace and needs disbanding.
It's odd we have quangos like ACE at arms length from government so that certain kinds of decisions don't get politicised, yet they end up making decisions that are even more politicised than ministers would. The purpose of these quangos in fact often seems to become making decisions for their political masters that the politicians want to be distanced from (Ofgem/NESO is another live example). The whole quango model needs a rethink.
If you want to bank some big savings you should take a look at Nesta. It's funded from a National Lottery endowment worth hundreds of millions. When New Labour set it up it was supposed to be focussed on encouraging British innovation, but it has essentially become a left-wing policy think tank (check out its Policy Live 2026 conference if you have the stomach). Forcing heat pumps on an unsuspecting British public is a particular obsession of theirs. Not, I think, what National Lottery punters would want their money spent on.
Wouldn't it be nice if philanthropists with lots of spare money backed artistic and educational projects and we admired them for doing it. What business has the state got here? If the Greens are to be believed billionaires can provide all the money we need to sort out society's problems. Maybe we could persuade these wealthy individuals to stop funding nebulous climate pressure groups and do some practical good. Then we could offer them tax incentives to stay in Britain and celebrate their generosity.
I partially agree with you. A lot of this stuff sounds like utter rubbish and a parody of wokeism that Rod Liddle might have made up. What a waste of time and money.
But the Tories need to be very careful here. There’s a clear fork in the road. Reform-lite: aping of Trump, attacking all minority-focused and “DEI” initiatives from an ideological standpoint, because “normal” people don’t want this sort of thing; or old-fashioned Conservative: a tolerant acceptance that this is small beer, and theatre and the arts have always been left wing and a bit bonkers, and let it do what it wants in a free country.
Reform would presumably create its own Arts Council approving only projects it considers culturally acceptable. I don’t think that’s where most Conservatives are.
Don’t be Reform-lite. Time to reclaim the millions of former moderate Conservatives you are alienating with your leave the ECHR, anti net zero culture war nonsense.
I think Neil is all in favour of letting the weird, wonderful, and politically naive flourish all over the UK. Me too.
He just doesn't want to pay for it. Me neither.
Really happy if someone wants to put together a show that excludes me because I'm pale and straight. It's all good, I won't go, I won't be upset, I won't call anybody racist. I just don't want to pay for it.
In return I don't expect anybody else's taxes to support shows where the audience can only be portly, middle-aged white guys.
This seems like a fair, and efficient, equilibrium to me.
You put this really well. This is radicalising - both in the sense that it describes funding for events that one presumes will radicalise some of their attendees, and in the sense that reading it makes me furious
Also scrap free entry to museums and galleries. A modest fee—say £15 for adults, with free entry for children—would be reasonable.
It could also make visiting them a more pleasant experience. Many are regularly at or beyond capacity, to the point where overcrowding can make the experience far less enjoyable.
The main beneficiaries of the current policy are Londoners and tourists, the majority of whom could afford to contribute towards the cost of running these institutions. The additional revenue could help support their long-term funding while allowing visitor numbers to be managed more effectively.
This is all pocket change though compared to the amount the Arts Council wastes on subsidising Opera in this country - an art form which is mainly attended by those who could afford to pay and which the common man on the street has no interest. This surely has to be the first place to start - the amount spent is virtue signally of the highest order so that the elites feel like they have done the 'right' thing
I think the criticisms you’re highlighting here are important. However, it’s also important to highlight the good work done via arts council funding. Some really important institutions such as the National Theatre, the RSC, plus important regional theatres benefit from arts council funding. They then work their socks off to sell tickets and raise money through private means. Many of them are badges of pride for the country; others are real local hubs for their community.
War Horse began at the National, Matilda began at the RSC, other shows like Operation Mincemeat (big, award winning global hit) received ACE funding.
How do you make sure you don’t throw the baby out with the bathwater here? How do you ensure that the good work done by art council grants continues, whilst some of it more identity-obsessed, less unifying projects plough their own furrow?
I think you do throw the baby out with the bathwater unfortunately - but theatre has been alive in this country for at least 500 years, and unsubsidized for nearly all of it. We can just return to a more basic, more vital theatrical tradition that doesn't involve grants, civil servants, ceos, 'degrees' in acting and arts administration.
We have had public subsidy for theatre in this country for 86 years. Things have changed a lot in that time. Back in 1940 there were fewer than 20,000 homes with TV sets…
I didn't know that. We've been putting theatre goers and thespians nobody would pay to see ahead of safer streets and better medical care for 86 years?
Not an answer to your excellent question, but one major problem for an organisation like ACE is that you can't meaningfully measure what it does. So instead it comes up with its own metrics like "the proportion of the workforce in the organisations we subsidize who are LGBTQIA+" (check out ACE's Equality, Diversity and Inclusion Review
2018-23) that it can cite and reliably meet by funding projects from organisations that claim to represent the relevant interest groups.
As well as being a stupid metric in its own right, it also creates a ratchet effect ("what! the proportion of the workforce in the organisations you subsidize who are LGBTQIA+ fell by a percentage point last year, is the ACE going MAGA?")
If you can get ACE to drop stupid metrics like these and come up with a sensible way to assess ACE performance I'm sure that would help achieve what you describe.
Business idea: DEI but based on postcodes and income groups. Quotas for people at the bottom will produce more economic output and a short term boost.
A billion is about 15 quid per person per year. Theres definitely improvements to be made, but this is sheer scapegoating of our minority communities (who also pay a lot of taxes). And coming from a Tory - The party who were literally responsible for years of austerity - it’s hypocrisy of the highest order - dont fall for this nonsense. Support your arts, they bring people together in so many ways.
If the author had chosen a different set of grants he could be be arguing for ACE instead of against - they support a wide range of projects.
#notalabourleftie
Amazing list. Somehow the United States manages to have world class symphony orchestras, theaters, art museums, artists, actors, musicians, ballet and modern dance companies… some of whom apply for and receive small, specific grants from the National Endowment for the Arts, state and municipal grants, and a whole lot of private foundation and non-profit funding. Barbaric!
We live in an era when two inconsistent ideas rule the minds of many:
1) No one can determine that one artwork is better than another.
2) Everyone knows for certain that the job of government is to promote victims over oppressors, and everyone already knows who is worthy of such privilege.
Sorry, couldn't read it all through the red mist of indignation
I worked 25 years in mid scale theatre and most of the Arts Council Wales supported stuff was dross that nobody wanted to see, especially the Welsh language stuff!
As a theatre we eventually told ACW to get stuffed as they were too woke and controlling. It's proved a good commercial move.
I think many taxpayers are incandescent at how their money is squandered.
This was covered in Bastiat’s ‘What is seen and what is not seen’ yet we still have the gov sticking its fingers in our pie and redistributing to favoured groups. We need to take a hatchet to the state so that ordinary people can benefit from their hard work.
My wife has spent 25 years slogging away earning a living as a performing musician. In all that time, as I've accompanied her on her travels, I've literally not seen a single ACE funded act which had any musical (or other) merit whatsoever.
The entertainment industry is very simple : if you are good enough, you can make a commercial living. If you're crap, then you can't, because nobody will pay money to see you. The entire ACE racket is an utter disgrace and needs disbanding.
I'd say there's also a lot of people who are semi-professional, who can do this work part-time.
It's odd we have quangos like ACE at arms length from government so that certain kinds of decisions don't get politicised, yet they end up making decisions that are even more politicised than ministers would. The purpose of these quangos in fact often seems to become making decisions for their political masters that the politicians want to be distanced from (Ofgem/NESO is another live example). The whole quango model needs a rethink.
If you want to bank some big savings you should take a look at Nesta. It's funded from a National Lottery endowment worth hundreds of millions. When New Labour set it up it was supposed to be focussed on encouraging British innovation, but it has essentially become a left-wing policy think tank (check out its Policy Live 2026 conference if you have the stomach). Forcing heat pumps on an unsuspecting British public is a particular obsession of theirs. Not, I think, what National Lottery punters would want their money spent on.
Wouldn't it be nice if philanthropists with lots of spare money backed artistic and educational projects and we admired them for doing it. What business has the state got here? If the Greens are to be believed billionaires can provide all the money we need to sort out society's problems. Maybe we could persuade these wealthy individuals to stop funding nebulous climate pressure groups and do some practical good. Then we could offer them tax incentives to stay in Britain and celebrate their generosity.
I think that's how it worked for many years.
I partially agree with you. A lot of this stuff sounds like utter rubbish and a parody of wokeism that Rod Liddle might have made up. What a waste of time and money.
But the Tories need to be very careful here. There’s a clear fork in the road. Reform-lite: aping of Trump, attacking all minority-focused and “DEI” initiatives from an ideological standpoint, because “normal” people don’t want this sort of thing; or old-fashioned Conservative: a tolerant acceptance that this is small beer, and theatre and the arts have always been left wing and a bit bonkers, and let it do what it wants in a free country.
Reform would presumably create its own Arts Council approving only projects it considers culturally acceptable. I don’t think that’s where most Conservatives are.
Don’t be Reform-lite. Time to reclaim the millions of former moderate Conservatives you are alienating with your leave the ECHR, anti net zero culture war nonsense.
I think Neil is all in favour of letting the weird, wonderful, and politically naive flourish all over the UK. Me too.
He just doesn't want to pay for it. Me neither.
Really happy if someone wants to put together a show that excludes me because I'm pale and straight. It's all good, I won't go, I won't be upset, I won't call anybody racist. I just don't want to pay for it.
In return I don't expect anybody else's taxes to support shows where the audience can only be portly, middle-aged white guys.
This seems like a fair, and efficient, equilibrium to me.
You put this really well. This is radicalising - both in the sense that it describes funding for events that one presumes will radicalise some of their attendees, and in the sense that reading it makes me furious
Also scrap free entry to museums and galleries. A modest fee—say £15 for adults, with free entry for children—would be reasonable.
It could also make visiting them a more pleasant experience. Many are regularly at or beyond capacity, to the point where overcrowding can make the experience far less enjoyable.
The main beneficiaries of the current policy are Londoners and tourists, the majority of whom could afford to contribute towards the cost of running these institutions. The additional revenue could help support their long-term funding while allowing visitor numbers to be managed more effectively.
This is all pocket change though compared to the amount the Arts Council wastes on subsidising Opera in this country - an art form which is mainly attended by those who could afford to pay and which the common man on the street has no interest. This surely has to be the first place to start - the amount spent is virtue signally of the highest order so that the elites feel like they have done the 'right' thing
Opera and ballet. Yeah, have to reluctantly agree.
Agree with this, and baulk at the idea of the BBC being funded by a household levy for not too dissimilar reasons
I think the criticisms you’re highlighting here are important. However, it’s also important to highlight the good work done via arts council funding. Some really important institutions such as the National Theatre, the RSC, plus important regional theatres benefit from arts council funding. They then work their socks off to sell tickets and raise money through private means. Many of them are badges of pride for the country; others are real local hubs for their community.
War Horse began at the National, Matilda began at the RSC, other shows like Operation Mincemeat (big, award winning global hit) received ACE funding.
How do you make sure you don’t throw the baby out with the bathwater here? How do you ensure that the good work done by art council grants continues, whilst some of it more identity-obsessed, less unifying projects plough their own furrow?
I think you do throw the baby out with the bathwater unfortunately - but theatre has been alive in this country for at least 500 years, and unsubsidized for nearly all of it. We can just return to a more basic, more vital theatrical tradition that doesn't involve grants, civil servants, ceos, 'degrees' in acting and arts administration.
We have had public subsidy for theatre in this country for 86 years. Things have changed a lot in that time. Back in 1940 there were fewer than 20,000 homes with TV sets…
I didn't know that. We've been putting theatre goers and thespians nobody would pay to see ahead of safer streets and better medical care for 86 years?
Not an answer to your excellent question, but one major problem for an organisation like ACE is that you can't meaningfully measure what it does. So instead it comes up with its own metrics like "the proportion of the workforce in the organisations we subsidize who are LGBTQIA+" (check out ACE's Equality, Diversity and Inclusion Review
2018-23) that it can cite and reliably meet by funding projects from organisations that claim to represent the relevant interest groups.
As well as being a stupid metric in its own right, it also creates a ratchet effect ("what! the proportion of the workforce in the organisations you subsidize who are LGBTQIA+ fell by a percentage point last year, is the ACE going MAGA?")
If you can get ACE to drop stupid metrics like these and come up with a sensible way to assess ACE performance I'm sure that would help achieve what you describe.