Alan Milburn is a serious, reform-minded politician. He’s tried to do good job of his review. But there is a problem: the reason it was commissioned was the welfare rebellion in June 2025 which ended Keir Starmer’s authority - and ultimately his premiership.
That means that the report isn’t really an objective analysis of Britain’s NEETs crisis. Milburn has had to shape his report to fit what Labour MPs are – and aren’t – willing to accept. And the answer to what they will accept is: “nothing difficult” - so Milburn hasn’t really had a free hand here.
What Burnham wants is the vibes of doing welfare reform but without any difficult bits - after all, attempting even minor reforms is one of the main reasons Starmer was kicked out and Burnham got the job.
They need to be seen to act given soaring youth unemployment and I think they feel slightly guilty about their role in creating this problem. Just as a reminder of that:
They massively hiked the jobs tax, and did so by cutting the threshold, meaning the impact was greatest for lower paid people (meaning it hit the young disproportionately)
They massively increased day one rights in the workplace with the Employment Bill, which makes it much less attractive to hire younger people
That is why:
The share of young people who are either unemployed or inactive is close to historic levels
40% of young people in London who are not in education are inactive or unemployed
The number of jobs held by young British people has actually gone down in the last year
For the first time, youth unemployment in the UK is worse than the EU average
They increased youth unemployment, so what is their answer now?
The Milburn review
Before getting into it, it’s worth briefly setting out how the Conservative Party would address the NEETs crisis. We would:
Halve Employer NICs for 21-24 year olds
End eligibility for sickness and income-replacement benefits for low-level mental health and disabilities (PIP and Universal Credit Health element)
Reduce benefits for young people who refuse to attend training (via our Get To Work Allowance).
We published the full details (including how we’d pay for it all) last week.
There are two halves to the review. One is about actually reforming the benefits system. It nods dutifully in the direction of reforms but stops short of saying anything specific at all, leaving everything to the future.
Here’s one example, paragraph 762:
762. Wider changes to child DLA are not within my review’s terms of reference, but I believe serious consideration should be given to far reaching reform of Child DLA
Yes! I agree - but we need to fix this now - not just acknowledge the problem.
It is the same for PIP too:
[…] For people under 25, PIP should therefore be replaced by a differentiated system that is better able to respond to those differing needs directly. The interim report of the Timms Review has rightly concluded that PIP is not fit for purpose and that both cash and services have a role to play in enabling disabled people.
Detailed gateway design needed for these changes will require further work
In one sense this is flattering - it sounds like he is copying Conservative policy. But pointing at the problem seems to be the limit of what Milburn has been allowed to do here - because the sort of changes that are actually meant here will bring Labour MPs out in rebellion.
It’s the same on tax where Milburn says government should
[…] lower employer National Insurance costs for workers aged 21 to 24 starting in the retail and hospitality sectors which together provide 37% of jobs for young people aged 16 to 24.
In one sense this is very brave: by recommending that the Government essentially unwinds the 2024 NICs rise for U25s, Milburn is admitting that, from its very first Budget, Labour’s decisions have made the NEETs crisis worse and contributed to unemployment. But even then, Milburn is forced to compromise and say this should only happen, “when fiscal conditions allow”.
There’s a huge amount of rebranding too. The below might sound like reforms, but without any detail on how the benefits gateway will actually be tightened they are just meaningless:
Create an “entirely new benefit system for young people”, which will lead to “some people [getting] less financial support… than under the current system”. This would include:
The Additional Cost Allowance: a “non-means tested” cash benefit for “disability-related extra costs”. But this is more or less the same as what PIP is today.
The “Severe and Complex Needs Insurance”: a “more generous long-term award… for the small minority of people… where it is already clear they will likely never be able to work”. But again, this is basically the same as UC Health element today.
Reducing benefits for “a young person who persistently refuses to engage”. But this already happens.
To some extent the analysis here is the same as ours. Employment costs are too high. Welfare is too easy to get. The system and the people within it don’t have the right incentives.
But the solutions have all kicked into the long grass. Only carrots are acceptable to Labour MPs - no sticks. The government has further set back the case for reform with their own Fonagy Review which claims, absurdly, there is no problem of over diagnosis of mental health.
So my fear is this will all go nowhere.
With actual welfare reform ruled off limits, what we’re left with is a set of circular job-creation schemes and subsidies.
Taxpayers will pay businesses to hire young people, to fix a youth unemployment crisis which the government created with massive increases in tax and regulation. Make it make sense!
And even the work-creation schemes are going to rollout very slowly, running into the next parliament.
150. By the early 2030s, there should be a fully functioning statutory participation system in place: a YOS in every place in England, legal Opportunity and Support Guarantees, strategic authority accountability, common data and standards, and funding organised around the participation objective. Critically, the NEET rate should be falling consistently with no 16 to 17 year-olds who are NEET.
Savings?
Even Milburn’s own report says there won’t be any savings from all this before 2036/7 – meaning the welfare bill won’t come down for over a decade.
But even this is much too generous.
I am incredibly sceptical that this package will ever deliver savings.
When we turn to the “analytical annex” of the report which is used to justify the claim there are some savings here we find… garbage. Right at the top it describes itself as being based on “rule of thumb”:

What the analytical annex does not tell you is… everything you might need to know!
For example:
How many people will be on which benefits in which years
How much money they will receive
How many people will be on which job creation scheme
What the costs and unit costs of each scheme will be
What assumptions are made about the employment impact of these schemes
What conditions will be affected by disability reforms
And so on and on.
This is not the first atrocity of this kind under this government - Government previous forecast major savings from SEND reforms but then refused to answer any questions about what their reforms or assumptions were. This is policy making reduced to pure vibes and guess work.
Conclusions
What Burnham wants is the vibes of doing welfare reform but without any difficult bits
There are lot of words here and no real changes.
The price of doing nothing will be paid by a generation of young people who have been chucked out of work by big increases in tax and regulation, laser targeted to hit them and make them less likely to get a job.
Labour are effectively agreeing today to do nothing for at least half a decade.
They are in office, but not in power. They are in charge, but have no idea where they are going. Once again I ask: what is the point of this government?


Do people in the UK understand that only 14% of those young people receive benefits—that is, 140,000 out of 1 million? That means 860,000 are receiving nothing, and the cost of those benefits is just 2.4% of all benefit spending in the UK. ( HMRC UK GOV. 2026)
So, I ask: why bash them when they hardly represent a burden on UK taxpayers? Once again, cruel "Mother England" is kicking her most vulnerable—her own youth—even when she pays nothing to 86% of them and shows no care for them.
By the way, they probably are active working online, because in real Britain after Brexit and 2008 Austerity Neoliberal Rape of the Country, they are definitely not going to do UBER or Deliveroo or AMAZON slave shite jobs.
«I think they feel slightly guilty about their role in creating this problem. Just as a reminder of that:
* They massively hiked the jobs tax [...] * They massively increased day one rights in the workplace»
There is an alternative major explanation: the global typical wage is £1-2 per hour and any business that chooses to pay £8-12 per hour instead of setting up premises in Morocco, Romania, Vietnam clearly is run by idiots. There is very high youth unemployment in China where wages are much lower than in the UK, and in Ethiopia where they are a small fraction (like £8-12 per month not per hour).
«40% of young people in London who are not in education are inactive or unemployed»
Our blogger has reported not so long ago that 50-60% of London employees are cheaper (and usually young) immigrants willing to take lower pay than british youth as they can accept a much more economical lifestyle.
The fundamental problem continues to be that young (and most other) britons have priced themselves out of the global job market and New Labour or the Conservatives or Reform UK cannot do anything about it because it is those excessive salary expectations that underwrite the stupendous levels of property prices and rents and other asset valuations.
If british workers were to be competitive with those of Morocco, Romania, Vietnam then the cost of living would need to fall to the levels of Morocco, Romania, Vietnam. Not going to happen anytime soon.
SO New Labour like the Conservatives and LibDems before them are just tinkering here and there in slightly different ways hoping to procrastinate as much as they can and as well documented by our blogger.